Bahai News - Ground-breaking conference in London explores the connection between science and morality
Ground-breaking conference in London explores the connection between science and morality
LONDON, 8 April 2002 (BWNS) -- Is there a scientific basis for morality? Is there a place in the
brain where the capacity for morality resides? These were just two of many thought-provoking questions
posed at a ground-breaking conference on the "Science of Morality" here on 8-9 February 2002.
Organized by surgeon Graham Walker and held at the Royal College of Physicians, Regents Park, the meeting
sought to examine the scientific evidence for a neurological location, genetic basis and/or an innate
capacity for morality.
"Wherever one looks inwardly and outwardly, one meets conflict, mostly because of the moral diversity
caused by differing perspectives of culture, religion, and age," said Dr. Walker, a prominent London head
and neck surgeon and a member of the Baha'i community of the United Kingdom. "In order to eliminate this
conflict, we must find a common ground."
Dr. Walker hopes to start building a body of respectable, affirmable evidence of a scientific basis for
morality which can act as a locus where varied disciplines can meet and agree.
More than 60 delegates representing a wide variety of medical, scientific and philosophical disciplines
attended the conference. Among the speakers were Ian Craig, a world renowned specialist on cyclogenetics
from the Institute of Psychiatry in London; Baroness Susan Greenfield, a professor of neuropharmacology at
Oxford University and president of the Royal Institute; Faraneh Vargha-Khadem, a professor of
neurosciences at the Institute of Child Health, University College, London; and Hossain Danesh, a
professor of psychiatry and president of Landegg International University in Switzerland.
Also addressing the event were Robin Dunbar, professor of biological sciences, Liverpool University;
Michael Penn, professor of psychology, Franklin and Marshall College, Pennsylvania; Sean Spence,
psychiatrist and academic radiologist; Adam Zeman of the department of clinical neurosciences in
Edinburgh; and Bill Hatcher, professor of mathematics and philosophy, Laval University, Canada.
"This conference was historic in that it brought together some of the world's most accomplished
researchers to explore, in an earnest, open, and cordial search for truth, the biological, psychological
and social factors that appear to be responsible for healthy moral development," said Dr. Penn, who
presented a paper suggesting that a necessary pre-condition for moral development is an understanding of
justice. "The scientists and philosophers participating in the conference are widely respected -- and so
the quality of scholarship and research was in itself, extremely inspiring.
Dr. Danesh delivered the keynote speech, exploring the consonance between science, religion and ethics.
His thesis was that humanity is moving from a self-centered, survival-oriented basis towards a
"Due to the fact that all individuals and societies are subject to the universal law of development and
progress, we are able to identify three distinctive worldviews that are present, to a lesser or greater
degree, in all human societies," said Dr. Danesh. "These worldviews reflect the particular characteristics
of three distinctive phases in the development of every individual and society, which are designated
respectively as survival-, identity-, and peace-centred worldviews.
Baroness Greenfield provoked a wide-ranging discussion with her thesis that there is no specific location
for the capacity of morality in the brain; rather it is essentially "hard-wired" in response to life
experience and genetics, said Dr. Walker.
"She said there is no such thing as a center of consciousness in the brain," said Dr. Walker. "Rather,
consciousness is spatially diffuse in the brain. At the same time, she said, it is temporally unified."
Other speakers, said Dr. Walker, presented evidence that suggest the fronto-orbital area of the brain
might be the location of a moral center. Specifically, he said, Dr. Vargha-Khadem and Dr. Spence of the
Department of Psychiatry at the University of Sheffield, UK, said some studies show that injuries to this
area before the age of 14 or 15 heal, while injuries sustained later in life seem to deprive an individual
of moral judgment.
"The late emergence of sociopathic profiles in children who have suffered early bilateral orbitofrontal
lesions suggests that perhaps these regions assume their functional significance later during childhood,
possibly after the onset of puberty," said Dr. Vargha-Khadem in response to questions after the
While the discussion was lively and provocative, Dr. Graham said, participants reached a general
conclusion that "there is a neurological aspect to morality, or the development of morality."
"This conclusion implies that if there is such a capacity, you can induce this with the right type of
exposure to experiences," said Dr. Walker. Alternatively, he said, it seems that exposure to negative
experiences might take an individual "down the other pathway to become immoral, and rather more likely to
be criminal or sociopathic."
Dr. Walker said he was inspired to organize the conference because of his practice of the Baha'i Faith.
"While the connection between religion and science is not unique to the Baha'i Faith, it is certainly a
strong tenet," he said. "If indeed there is a consonance between science and religion, then it should be
extendable to concepts like spirituality and morality, which is one of the main pillars of religiosity."
A book of the conference proceedings has been commissioned by the Royal College of Physicians.
©Copyright 2002, Baha'i World News Service
Page last updated/revised 020409
Return to the Bahá'í Association's Main Web Page